Low carbon investing without compromising returns
It is hard to avoid opening a newspaper or listening to the news without some reference to climate change. Increasingly, investors are looking for a more environmentally friendly way to invest their money – a trend we have seen well before the recent devastating bushfires in Australia. The Russell Investments Australian Responsible Investment ETF (RARI) is listed on the ASX. Here we take a closer look at how RARI stack up versus the broader Australian Share market.
When investors look at their investments from a climate change perspective, they typically focus on two factors:
- Carbon emissions (the carbon footprint of a company)
- Carbon reserves (fossil fuel assets still in the ground and yet to be extracted)
All companies have some kind of carbon footprint, but in an index like the S&P/ASX 200 the bulk of carbon emissions tends to come from a relatively concentrated number of companies and sectors. Carbon reserves are fossil fuel assets held by an even more select group of companies and these ‘assets’ are held on their balance sheets. For some time now, there has been a concern by investors that such assets would become ‘stranded’ i.e. they will never be able to be mined, as countries strive to meet their obligations under the 2015 ‘Paris Agreement’ to limit global temperature increases to below 2°C. It is widely accepted by everyone but the most extreme ‘climate deniers’ that the release of carbon into the atmosphere is a key reason for global warming. Earlier this month, the Financial Times ran an article once again citing the risks of investing in fossil fuel heavy companies:
Source: Financial Times
Most ‘low carbon’ strategies in share markets will typically take underweight positions to the three most carbon intensive sectors: energy, materials, and utilities. These three sectors make up around 25% of the Australian share market, double that of a global share market index such as the MSCI World ex Australia. This is driven by index heavyweights BHP and Rio Tinto, which results in a much higher weight to materials in our domestic market. Consequently, the ‘carbon footprint’ measure of the Australian share market is around 40% higher than the MSCI World ex Australia.
RARI was the first ESG ETF listed in Australia and the starting point for the portfolio construction process is a stock exclusion approach that is overseen by a Responsible Investment Committee (“RI Committee”). The RI Committee implements a broad set of widely accepted exclusions for responsible investment - removing stocks with material interests in alcohol, gambling, controversial weapons and fossil fuels. Fossil fuel related exclusions result in the biggest impact – not surprising given the make-up of the Australian share market.
March 2019 RARI review
Last year, the RI Committee updated the fossil fuels exclusion to remove all stocks that hold carbon reserves. This was the most significant change to the exclusion process since the launch of RARI in 2015 – and reflected a growing concern by investors, and the RI Committee, around fossil fuel intensive companies. RARI was already underweight high-carbon emitting stocks, but the rules that governed the index construction meant that the ETF still had a material absolute exposure to the energy sector. By adding a carbon reserves exclusion, RARI’s exposure to the Energy sector dropped significantly. Since then WorleyParsons, a company that provides professional services to the mining sector, is the only stock held in the energy sector. This has proved to be a well-timed move by the RI Committee as energy stocks have underperformed significantly since the exclusion was implemented:
Source: S&P/ASX 200
The removal of companies with carbon reserves has also helped lower RARI’s carbon footprint – its’ portfolio carbon footprint measure is now around half that of the S&P/ASX 200.
Russell Investments Responsible Investment ETF
|Carbon Reserves (Relative to ASX 200)||0%|
|Carbon Footprint (Relative to ASX 200)||53%|
Source: Russell Investments As at 31 Dec. 2019
Renewable Energy and Lowering Carbon Emissions
There are not many companies that focus purely on renewable energy, particularly in Australia, but RARI has an overweight position in one – utility Infigen Energy. Many other companies however have been proactive in changing their business model with a goal to reduce climate impact. Rio Tinto sold off its coal assets some time ago and, like BHP, has been engaging with investors to set targets to lower their carbon footprint and position for a much lower carbon economy.
Australia relies on fossil fuels for its’ Energy needs and this trend does not appear to be changing anytime soon. Natural gas will grow in importance as coal fired stations are phased out, as recent announcements by the NSW and Federal governments have indicated. However, burning gas to produce power also releases a high level of carbon in to the atmosphere and, whilst gas as a ‘transition fuel’ makes sense in the short-term, much more can be done to ensure renewable energy plays a bigger role for our energy needs in the long term. Greater vision and longer-term thinking are required from the Federal Government so that Australia’s energy production is more closely aligned with governments in Europe, who have been the most proactive to date in positioning their countries for the energy transition.
Scotland, once known for its’ oil and gas reserves in the North Sea, will host the next United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP26) and has joined Sweden in passing legislation to have net zero emissions within the next 30 years. ‘Net zero emissions’ for individual countries looks sure to dominate the agenda at COP26; it will be interesting to see if Australia adopts a different tone to that taken in 2019 when it was one of the countries accused of blocking a deal on climate impact.
Investing in RARI will not impact climate change, but it will provide investors with a diversified portfolio of Australian shares with materially lower exposure to the risks from carbon emissions and reserves.