Interim Asset Management

A cost- and risk-minimising solution for restructuring assets

Partner with us

Compared to traditional approaches, interim asset management promises ease of use and significant cost savings.

Some common reasons for making an investment manager change include portfolio manager lift-outs, investment manager closure of the business or winding down a specific strategy, scandals or improper conduct and underperformance. In these scenarios, there is typically a desire to make a change quickly, but investors can be faced with options that are not ideal and can leave assets in limbo while a new manager is vetted and selected. Often this manager search and selection process can take months to complete.

There is a better way to manage your exposure when switching investment managers

Once the decision has been made to terminate an existing manager or mandate, institutional investors are then faced with what to do with the assets until a new manager is selected and under contract. We believe there is an ideal way to handle this situation, but let’s first review some of the more common, but less than ideal solutions to this challenge.

Leave the mandate with the existing manager (where able)
Terminate the mandate and require care and maintenance
Restructure the mandate to a passive mandate

Each of these options has a number of disadvantages, which tend to outweigh any potential advantages:

LEAVE THE MANDATE WITH THE EXISTING MANAGER (WHERE ABLE)

Advantages

Least amount of work/administrative ease.

Disadvantages

Concerns over governance of your organisation's assets. If you're holding on to a manager whose confidence has been lost, are you really doing your fiduciary duty?
Continuing to pay for active management fees when the active manager's insights are no longer desired.
A junior portfolio manager could potentially take charge of your portfolio. This often arises in instances where the old manager has been lifted out. You may be left with a manager you've potentially never researched.

Terminate the mandate and require care and maintenance

Advantages

Administrative ease.
Compared to the do-nothing approach, perhaps governance is at least improved under this approach, as no new active decisions are being made by the manager in which confidence has been lost.

Disadvantages

Still sitting on active bets taken by the manager that will become stale over time.
No real active oversight over the portfolio, let along accountability for it.
Continuing to pay active management fees.

Restructure to a passive mandate

Advantages

Administrative ease.

Disadvantages

Transitioning from active to passive management, and then back to active, can be very costly due to the transaction fees incurred from buying and selling assets at both stages.
You've been paying active management fees to achieve specific alpha targets or investment exposures. Transitioning away from an actively managed portfolio could increase the risk of not meeting your investment objectives.

The costs of these simplistic approaches are significant

The one consistent advantage seen in all three is the ease-of-use factor – that is, the lack of an administrative burden.

What if there was a solution that could satisfy both of these needs and relieve the administrative burden while still saving on cost? We believe the solution to this exists in a fourth option – interim asset management.

The better option: Interim Asset Management

Interim asset management is an investment management solution provided by some interim managers, like Russell Investments, as they have specialist teams who are not only ideally placed to "transition" the assets being restructured in a manner that minimises costs and risk, but is also held accountable for the performance of the portfolio during the interim period between the departure of the old manager and the onboarding of the new manager. During this timeframe, the assets are held in an implementation account set up by the interim manager.

Meanwhile, the interim manager is responsible for minimising the performance impact of the portfolio restructure and maintaining the desired investment exposure. This includes employing strategies, such as derivatives, that minimise unnecessary trading costs for the asset owner, in addition to mitigating unrewarded risks. This eliminates so-called performance holidays, ensuring there are no gaps in overall performance.

Just as important, the workload is transferred from the asset owner to the interim manager, preventing vital resources in the organisation from becoming overly burdened by non-core administrative tasks. As a result, the asset owner often receives active management with reduced risk without paying the active management fees.

Overview

Interim Management

Explore more through this at-a-glance overview covering our capabilities.

Advantages of Interim Asset Management

Costs

Optimised beta exposure and a reduction in trading and transaction costs by consolidating multiple transitions.

In-kind transfers

Maximise in-kind transfers with each transition.

Flexibility

Increased flexibility, nimbleness and the ability to efficiently leave the legacy manager.

Utilise securities

Ability to utilise existing securities to fund new manager once chosen.

CASE STUDY 1
CASE STUDY 2
CASE STUDY 3

Building an optimised representation of the MSCI ACWI

A client of ours, wanting to get out of a global mandate, initially tasked us with building a full representation of the MSCI All Country World Index.

Our team was able to analyse the client’s portfolio and build an optimised portfolio of individual securities and a few ETFs, tracking the index within 35 basis points (bps) of annualised tracking error. We were able to retain a significant amount of the legacy portfolio by only purchasing approximately 1,200 names in the index – leading to dramatic savings in trading costs and custody fees.

After the initial optimisation, the client used this as an implementation account for the next six years. The account fluctuated between $200 million and $5 billion in value, depending upon what the client was doing, with the client transitioning in and out of the implementation account eight to ten times per year.

Transition from AJO

AJO Partners announced that it would be closing its doors at the end of 2020, meaning that clients would need to move their assets to another investment manager.

Ultimately, we were hired by seven clients to take over their AJO portfolios, trim the tracking error risk from around 4% of the benchmark to somewhere around 1.5% to 2% of the benchmark, and then manage the assets on an interim basis until the clients could find a long-term solution with another investment manager.

The clients chose to go with a 1.75% tracking error to the benchmark (with an estimated cost of 12.5 bps, +/-14.2 bps), which saved them an estimated 34 bps in transaction costs versus going all the way to the index. We were able to achieve these results with only a 15% turnover in the portfolio, while still maintaining their desired investment exposure.

Pension plan with EM Debt Manager

In early 2020, a public pension plan approached us as they wanted to terminate an emerging market debt manager but still needed to contract a new manager.

We helped evaluate a few options to provide various risk and cost scenarios. This analysis also factored across multiple turnover scenarios, ranging from 5% to 20%, and the risks and cost impacts associated with each scenario. Ultimately, we reduced the tracking error by approximately 40% by turning over just 5% of the portfolio while preserving the desired investment exposure.

Customized Portfolio Solutions

Specialist expertise and strategies to help your team gain greater portfolio control, limit costs, reduce risk, and enhance returns.

Transition Management

We assist our clients in managing their investment performance and risks when restructuring their portfolios or asset classes.

Overlay Services

An essential tool for managing large pools of capital as derivative overlays help manage risk elements and improve performance.

Currency Management

Manage foreign exchange (FX) trading costs and currency risk by drawing upon our currency investment team and FX trading specialists.

Trading and Execution

Execution solutions to achieve enhanced returns using the latest advances in technology to find liquidity, reduce transaction costs and manage risk.

Completion Portfolios

Maximise control of risk-adjusted returns and reduce production cost while aligning investments with your beliefs - all through a multi-manager approach.

Enhanced Portfolio Implementation

A platform designed for asset managers that combines all advisory models and investment insights into one centrally managed, segregated account.

Implementation resources

Quarterly Trading Report

Q4 2024: Volatility returns

Read the summary

Managing Exposures Knowledge Exchange

How exposed are you? When it comes to risk management, we've got you covered.

View the exchange

Institutional Trading Calendar

Identify which days in the year have greater potential for elevated risk or reduced market liquidity.

View the calandar

Your portfolio deserves specialist oversight and management at all times - especially during times of change. We have the experience and deep capability set to help you manage your exposures and navigate the challenging road ahead. Let us know how we can help.

Partner with us

Get in touch with us through this form and we'll reach out to you.

Chris Frost

Associate Director, UK Institutional

About Chris