What might tax liability mean to you?
This is a hypothetical illustration and not meant to represent an actual investment strategy.
Taxes may be due at some point in the future and tax rates may be different when they are. Here’s a hypothetical example that shows the potential impact of taxes on an investment portfolio. Our prudent investor, we’ll call him James, has a $1 million nest egg. Over the next 10 years he has three options for investing that money. One strategy is fully tax-managed and successfully defers all gain recognition to a later date. The second treats all gains as long-term gains for the funds, but in doing so incurs taxes of 23.8% (rate for those in the top tax bracket) each year. The third approach chases short-term gains, which results in the annual gain being taxed as short term and treated as ordinary income at 43.4%. As you can see in the chart, the fully tax-managed strategy could potentially help net big gains, more than doubling the initial investment. Going after only long-term gains in this hypothetical situation looks good if taken by itself, but less appealing when matched against the fully tax-managed strategy. And if James chooses to chase short-term gains -- ouch! That approach could potentially yield half the gains of a tax-managed strategy. Yet, it’s understandable that people might choose the initial potential returns of short-term gains because the high activity of buying and selling can seem appealing. But that is only part of the story especially when the potential tax consequences are not taken into account. So what could investors do when their goal is not to avoid paying tax, but to help gain higher after-tax wealth? The key may be to locate investment funds in a manner that’s right for their tax status. For instance, an investor might have a stock portfolio that turns over rapidly, maybe 100% or more within a year. Such turnover can create a lot of short-term capital gains, which, as we’ve seen in the above example, also incurs the highest tax. So any portfolio like that might serve an investor’s goals better by being under a more tax-friendly investing umbrella, such as a 401(k). Commodities can be another tax-unfriendly investment vehicle, so they too may serve an investor’s tax-managed investing strategies best by being held in accounts that have a tax- deferred or tax-exempt status. (I’ll write later about portfolio turnover that can be good for reducing taxes through a process called loss harvesting). Just know that there is “good” turnover and “bad” turnover in regards to taxes. Other investments that can be tax-friendly, such as municipal bonds, can go into accounts that have a bigger tax load. Tax-managed mutual funds are another way to help lower the tax burden on investments.