Ten by Ten 10 of the world's leading institutional investors 10 of the world's leading asset managers

seeking returns icon

Part 3: Investors' Methods for Seeking Returns

The 10x10 report

Part 3: Investors' methods for seeking returns

If the low-return environment is real, then what are both asset managers and asset owners doing about it? How are both groups addressing low interest rates? How large of a role do they expect private markets and alternatives to play in portfolios? And what impact has downward fee pressure put on both asset manager and asset owners?

The 10x10 Report - independently implemented by research consultant, Cerulli Associates - addresses these topics from the points of view of 10 of the world’s leading institutional investors. Those views are then contrasted with 10 of the world’s leading asset managers.

Investors' methods for seeking returns report

headshot of Kate El-Hillow, Chief Investment Officer

Kate El-Hillow

President & Chief Investment Officer, Russell Investments

Kate's Take

Private markets investing a key focus for return-seeking strategies for leading institutional investors.

This finding of part three of the 10x10 report aligns with our own beliefs. The reason is obvious. The private markets category is too powerful of a tool not to consider. It's why we've worked so hard to expand our own private markets capabilities. We also found alignment in some of the three key features called out by the participants of this study: illiquidity, access, and a total-portfolio approach.

Liquidity in the private markets space

While a number of participants noted the liquidity issue of private markets, several of those surveyed in this study called out the "smoothing effect" of private markets investing: "Because these investments are not marked to market but are instead marked at book value, having them in a portfolio helps limit volatility." At Russell Investments, we have also found that the amount of illiquidity an institutional investor can tolerate is often much higher than they may think. And different categories of private markets investments have different cashflow profiles. For example, in a typical buyout fund, investors can reasonably expect to receive their capital commitments by years 7-8. But in private credit, the timeline is shorter, with committed capital being returned by years 5-6.

Access to the top-tier

Even for investors as large as the household-name participants of this study, access to the top private markets opportunities presents a challenge. One corporate retirement plan sponsor was quoted as saying, “We want to make contact with private equity managers, but do not have direct access with highly qualified ones.” We hear similar comments from many institutional investors and have clear advice in this area: Work with a strategic partner who can give you top-tier access.

This Cerulli study does an excellent job explaining the importance of access. It states: “The private investment space is known for its large performance dispersion between managers. This means that the private investment universe’s superior performance is skewed, or disproportionately attributed to the top-performing general partners. The skewed performance means that general partners with good track records generally have more bargaining power in terms of things like fee negotiation. It also means the top performers can almost pick and choose their investors. When raising funds, they can go to the largest asset owners and are not burdened with managing a multitude of small relationships. This is why access to private investments is increasingly something investors focus on. It’s also one of the key value-adds of working with an OCIO.” I don’t feel the need to add much to this, other than to reiterate the importance of ensuring your OCIO provider does indeed have the access you require.

The importance of a total-portfolio approach to private markets

As the chief investment officer of the firm that serves the leading institutional investors of this study, taking a total-portfolio approach to any aspect of investing is key, but for private markets, it is fundamental. One corporate plan sponsor was quoted in this study as saying, “Private equity—you can’t do tactically. They are long-term in nature and difficult to reverse course.”

When it comes to private markets, the opportunities are significant, but, as the plan sponsor above points out, they can be harder to unwind. There are more ways than ever before to access private markets. And while this may mean more prospects for customization, it also means more complexity. Work with a partner that knows how to build a total portfolio, knows how to balance both privates and publics, and knows how to dynamically manage portfolio changes over time.

About the 10x10 report

In 3Q 2021, Russell Investments held its annual Partner Innovation Lab, a roundtable event where large asset owners from various geographies brainstorm their greatest concerns and areas of interest. We asked Cerulli Associates to interview participating organisations, as well as some of our asset management partners, to extract individual perspectives on topics discussed at the event.

The result is a three-part series:

investors seeking returns icon

Part 3: Investors' Methods for Seeking Returns
(This report)

Participating institutional investors included the following corporate retirement plan sponsors, in alphabetical order: The Boeing Company, Fujitsu Global, Mazda Motor Corporation, Microsoft, Mitsubishi Electric, Nestlé, Roche and Unilever. It also included the following non-profit investors: The New York Presbyterian Hospital, Robert Wood Johnson Foundation and Thomas Jefferson University.

Participating alternative asset managers included: Brevan Howard, Hamilton Lane and Oaktree Capital Management. Participating fixed-income asset managers included: BlueBay Asset Management and Western Asset Management Company. And participating multi-asset-class managers included BlackRock, J.P. Morgan Asset Management, Morgan Stanley, Putnam Investments and Wellington Management.

Return-seeking issues

Coming off the heels of fiscal-year 2021, a period in which many investors posted superior performance, asset owner and managers expect a lower return environment going forward. In addition to challenges associated with a lower return outlook, managers must look for ways to adapt to a lower fee environment, namely employing measures to reduce costs.

Some of the worlds’ largest asset owners and managers shared insights on their views on the future return environment, the outlook for private markets investing and fee compression. Cerulli found that asset owners and managers generally agree on a lower return outlook and that private markets offer an avenue through which investors can maintain return targets, to an extent. Numerous 10X10 participants noted that private investments are not insulated from the lower return environment. That said, many investors with existing allocations to traditional private equity are looking to expand their portfolios into different sectors of the private investment landscape, including growth, venture capital, and private fixed income.

The future return environment

Most asset owners and managers expect lower returns in 2022 and beyond. This group predominantly believes that central banks have run out of policy tools they can use to propel markets.

Several participants told Cerulli that they have lowered their return targets to match their current outlook. One asset manager told Cerulli that most of its clients have incrementally lowered their return targets over the past 10 years, specifying that it is difficult for institutions to make drastic changes to their return targets because it has implications for flows (required contributions and distributions). This manager told Cerulli that its clients generally reduced their return targets from 25 to 50 basis points, annually.

From the experts:

white pencil

"The longer it goes on, the greater the worries become that we get that asset price bubble. Even though we aren’t out of the crisis, we are emerging with valuations that are fuller than they have been in other financial crises."

- Asset manager

black pencil

"If you have an incremental dollar, where do you want to put it? Equities are fully valued. Do you want to be buying bonds? Maybe if you think its QE forever…[The] other place is private equity and venture capital, but there’s a ton of capital on the sideline. The valuations are very rich. [There is] not much value anywhere."

- Asset owner

Private markets

For those seeking to move up the risk spectrum and target higher returns, private markets and private fixed income, specifically, are key areas of interest. Investors that have already made headway into the private investment space are looking to expand from traditional private equity (i.e., leveraged buyouts) into growth and venture capital.

Illiquidity is a distinguishing characteristic of private markets investing. While it is often cited as the source of premiums, participating asset owners and managers noted that it is not the sole source of premiums. Namely, premiums derived from the asset class are better described as complexity and access premiums, the former reflecting how investments are being managed and the latter reflecting how investments are brought together. Several 10X10 participants noted that illiquidity offers other benefits, including a smoothing effect on returns that insulate investors from temperamental changes in sentiment and being subject to otherwise-larger swings in required contributions.

Key objectives of private investment strategies 2021

From the experts:

white pencil

"What we are seeing today is a tremendous desire for private markets. That move is not finished; clients still want private markets where they can find yield and are willing to take more risk—either volatility risk, credit risk, or illiquidity risk—to fulfill their target returns."

- Asset manager

black pencil

"Private equity—you can’t do tactically; they are long-term in nature and difficult to reverse course. So the allocations we made 10 years ago, we are cognizant of how we are reinvesting this capital."

- Asset owner

Downward fee pressure

In addition to a lower return outlook, asset managers must navigate an environment of declining margins. As bargaining power continues to shift towards investors, managers have been subject to fee pressure and greater service-level expectations. To remain competitive, many have leveraged high-quality client service capabilities and offered advice beyond the scope of traditional mandates. A common approach to control costs is leveraging technology to streamline their operations and increase efficiencies in client service initiatives. 10X10 participants noted that even private investment firms, which have traditionally been more insulated from fee pressure, may begin to feel effects in the coming years. Additionally, these firms are subject to the same trend of higher expectations surrounding client service.

From the experts:

white pencil

"There’s no question that the amount of services we provide has gone up. For the dollar of income we got 30 years ago, that has gone down because we are doing far more for our clients."

- Asset manager

black pencil

"We aren’t of the mindset that lower fees are always better, because you get what you pay for. All things equal, lower fees are better, but we’ve tried to make sure we are ever diligent that our fees are incredibly competitive."

- Asset owner

This is just a snapshot. Download report below.

Investors' methods for seeking returns report